• News
  • Film and TV
  • Music
  • Tech
  • Features
  • Celebrity
  • Politics
  • Weird
  • Community
  • Advertise
  • Terms
  • Privacy & Cookies
  • LADbible Group
  • LADbible
  • SPORTbible
  • GAMINGbible
  • Tyla
  • UNILAD Tech
  • FOODbible
  • License Our Content
  • About Us & Contact
  • Jobs
  • Latest
  • Topics A-Z
  • Authors
Facebook
Instagram
X
Threads
TikTok
YouTube
Submit Your Content
Artist sued over taping banana to wall

Home> News

Published 17:31 20 Aug 2022 GMT+1

Artist sued over taping banana to wall

Artists Maurizio Cattelan and Joe Morford are involved in an acrimonious debate surrounding bananas taped to walls

Tom Wood

Tom Wood

A judge has ruled that a lawsuit against an Italian artist who stuck a banana to a wall with tape and sold it can go ahead.

The slightly bizarre suit alleges that Maurizio Cattelan has copied the artwork of Joe Morford from 2000, when he also made a piece in which bananas and oranges were taped to a panel.

If that’s not strange enough, some people actually bought Cattelan’s creations for more than $100,000, which means there’s going to be some money riding on this case.

Advert

It's not the first time this artwork has caused controversy – another artist staged his own performance piece by walking up and eating one version of it back in 2019.

Basically, American artist Morford accuses Cattelan of infringing on his intellectual property after the Italian released his work ‘Comedian’.

‘Comedian’ – Morford claims – bears a striking similarity to ‘Banana & Orange’ that he created two decades ago.

Advert

On his Facebook page, he wrote: “I did this in 2000. But some dude steals my junk and pimps it for 120K+ in 2019. Plagiarism…?”

Both bananas were taped to a panel, and both at a slight angle.

Cattelan claims that his buyers were actually buying instructions on how to install the artwork and display it, and that Morford’s fruit was synthetic, so he ‘cannot own the idea of a real banana duct-taped to a wall’.

However, a judge has now ruled that the case can go ahead.

Advert

US district judge Robert N Scola Jr said that Morford can proceed because ‘the alleged infringement of Morford’s banana is sufficient, quantitatively and qualitatively, to state a claim'.

The offending banana.
Court Documents

Morford further claims that Cattelan could have seen his work because it’s been on his website as well as Facebook and YouTube for years.

In his statement the judge mused on whether the work can be considered art at all given the nature of it.

Advert

He wrote: “Can a banana taped to a wall be art? Must art be beautiful? Creative? Emotive? A banana taped to a wall may not embody human creativity, but it may evoke some feelings, good or bad.

“In any event, a banana taped to a wall recalls [philosopher] Marshall McLuhan’s definition of art: ‘anything you can get away with’.”

He continued: “No one can claim a copyright in ideas, so Morford cannot claim a copyright in the idea of affixing a banana to a vertical plane using duct tape.

“Nor can Morford claim a copyright in bananas or duct tape.”

Advert

The work Morford claims was plagiarised.
Joe Morford/Facebook

With regard to whether it can be considered intellectual property, he concluded: “While using silver duct tape to affix a banana to a wall may not espouse the highest degree of creativity, its absurd and farcical nature meets the ‘minimal degree of creativity’ needed to qualify as original.”

So, not a fan then?

Either way, we’ll eventually find out whether Morford’s case will be a fruitful one, or whether it is rotten to the core.

Advert

If you have a story you want to tell, send it to UNILAD via [email protected] 

Featured Image Credit: Court Documents

Topics: Art, Weird, World News

Tom Wood
Tom Wood

Tom Wood is a LADbible journalist and Twin Peaks enthusiast. Despite having a career in football cut short by a chronic lack of talent, he managed to obtain degrees from both the University of London and Salford. According to his French teacher, at the weekend he mostly likes to play football and go to the park with his brother. Contact Tom on [email protected]

X

@TPWagwim

Advert

Advert

Advert

Choose your content:

12 mins ago
24 mins ago
an hour ago
2 hours ago
  • 12 mins ago

    Truth behind whether Trump can actually deport Elon Musk as the billionaire has ominous response to president's threat

    Trump made clear he was open to the possibility of Musk being deported

    News
  • 24 mins ago

    Diddy's rapper ex Yung Miami labeled 'gross' for posting questionable Justin Bieber video following his verdict

    Diddy's verdict result has seen many celebs react online

    Celebrity
  • an hour ago

    Father of teen who stepped off 120ft slope in front of him issues emotional update on his condition

    Zane Wach and his dad were climbing Mount Whitney when the incident occurred

    News
  • 2 hours ago

    Experts' urgent 'sextortion' warning as 14-year-old boy dies 35 minutes after 'flirting with girl' online

    The National Crime Agency has broken down how the blackmail can take place

    News
  • Man who spent $6,200,000 on ‘artwork’ of a banana taped to wall reveals what he’s going to do with it
  • 'Blue Scrotum' performer speaks out following backlash from Olympic viewers over 'offensive' set
  • Emotional footage of artist who allowed people to do anything to her shows what happened when ex joined extreme act
  • Shocking footage shows moment 'disrespectful' tourist breaks 'Van Gogh' chair covered in crystals after sitting on it