unilad homepage
unilad homepage
    • News
      • UK News
      • US News
      • World News
      • Crime
      • Health
      • Money
      • Sport
      • Travel
    • Music
    • Technology
    • Film and TV
      • News
      • DC Comics
      • Disney
      • Marvel
      • Netflix
    • Celebrity
    • Politics
    • Advertise
    • Terms
    • Privacy & Cookies
    • LADbible Group
    • LADbible
    • SPORTbible
    • GAMINGbible
    • Tyla
    • UNILAD Tech
    • FOODbible
    • License Our Content
    • About Us & Contact
    • Jobs
    • Latest
    • Archive
    • Topics A-Z
    • Authors
    Facebook
    Instagram
    X
    Threads
    TikTok
    YouTube
    Submit Your Content
    Doctor reveals how the 3-second food rule affects your health and what really matters

    Home> News> Health

    Published 18:18 7 Nov 2024 GMT

    Doctor reveals how the 3-second food rule affects your health and what really matters

    The answer may surprise you

    Poppy Bilderbeck

    Poppy Bilderbeck

    google discoverFollow us on Google Discover
    Featured Image Credit: ITV/Getty Stock Image

    Topics: Health, Science, Food and Drink, This Morning

    Poppy Bilderbeck
    Poppy Bilderbeck

    Poppy Bilderbeck is a freelance journalist with words in Daily Express, Cosmopolitan UK, LADbible, UNILAD and Tyla. She is a former Senior Journalist at LADbible Group. She graduated from The University of Manchester in 2021 with a First in English Literature and Drama, where alongside her studies she was Editor-in-Chief of The Tab Manchester. Poppy is most comfortable when chatting about all things mental health, is proving a drama degree is far from useless by watching and reviewing as many TV shows and films as possible.

    Advert

    Advert

    Advert

    A doctor has weighed in on whether food is actually safe to eat after dropping it on the floor for three seconds.

    Some of us call it the 10-second rule - it can't just be me, right? - others five and some the three-second rule, but when you drop food on the floor is it really safe to pick up and pop in your mouth?

    The experiment

    Well, during an appearance on British daytime TV show This Morning, Dr Zoe Williams explained Manchester Metropolitan University conducted a study to find out.

    The experiment saw different food items dropped on the floor for three, five and ten seconds and then picked back up and checked for contamination with any harmful bacteria that was 'purposefully placed on the floor'.

    Advert

    The results? Prepare to rethink your counting.

    Do you use the three, five or 10-second rule? (Getty Stock Images/ Indeed)
    Do you use the three, five or 10-second rule? (Getty Stock Images/ Indeed)

    Whether food is still safe to eat

    Dr Williams revealed: "There was a slight difference depending on the amount of time, so there is a thread of truth that the quicker you pick it up, the less contaminated it might be. But what they actually found was that it depends more on the type of food."

    Basically, if the food is 'high in sugar or salt' then bacteria find it harder to contaminate, for example, a slice of ham. And the amount of bacteria which ended up on the food also changed depending on whether the food was dry or wet.

    'The safest food to drop on the floor', pick up in between three to 10 seconds and then consume? The good old biscuit of course - both dry and sugary.

    But what are Dr Williams' own recommendations off the back of the study?

    She said: "I think the sensible thing to say, as a doctor, I have to say I cannot say it is safe to pick up food off the floor but it largely depends on the floor, doesn't it?"

    So, if you haven't hoovered or mopped in a while, it's probably best to just toss it in the trash.

    Dr Williams wouldn't recommend eating food picked up off the floor (Getty Stock Images/ Joebelanger)
    Dr Williams wouldn't recommend eating food picked up off the floor (Getty Stock Images/ Joebelanger)

    It's not taken long for people to share their thoughts.

    One Instagram user said: "I have labradors, food never hits the floor."

    Another added: "My god mother used to say eat a peck of dirt before you die. A peck is a unit of volume that is equal to 8 quarts, 2 gallons, or 16 pints. She lived to be 103."

    While a third wrote: "My parents always encouraged us to because it would build up our immune systems."

    And a fourth resolved: "I think it depends what it is… if you have more then bin it... But if its the last one then its mine… lol."

    Choose your content:

    3 hours ago
    4 hours ago
    • ANDREW CABALLERO-REYNOLDS/AFP via Getty Images
      3 hours ago

      America's national debt is now bigger than the entire economy for the first time since WWII

      President Trump says the economy is doing great - but these figures tell a very different story

      News
    • Alex Wong/Getty Images
      3 hours ago

      Pokémon fans just spotted a clue there's a new monster inspired by Barack Obama

      Pokémon fans have bought together a hidden clue: A real-life sea slug and a former US president

      News
    • WREG
      3 hours ago

      Activist trying to infiltrate Epstein's island claims he was hogtied by locals in violent altercation

      Benjamin Owen is the founder of We Fight Monsters, a non-profit organization based in Memphis

      News
    • 4th Judicial Circuit of Florida Courthouse via ProPublica
      4 hours ago

      Pregnant woman speaks out after being forced to be on zoom court call while she was in labor

      The case has reignited debate over whether pregnant women have rights over their own bodies

      News
    • Biochemist reveals what 'no added sugar' really means after discovering how food industry has been 'lying'
    • Doctor reveals how much water you need to drink per day and what happens if you don't
    • Disturbing reason why one can of diet soda can be worse for your health than regular soda
    • Minute-by-minute breakdown reveals the impact energy drinks really have on your body