Judge lets woman's young daughter decide punishment in her case as she gets emotional in court

Home> Community

Judge lets woman's young daughter decide punishment in her case as she gets emotional in court

Her mom was in court facing a ticket and featured on TV show, Caught in Providence

Kids say the darndest things, right?

They love to 'accidentally' get their moms and dads in trouble, and this adorable six-year-old certainly wasn't helping her mother's situation.

Sofia's mom was previously facing Judge Frank Caprio, the chief judge of the municipal court of Providence, Rhode Island, for a ticket - however, the type of ticket wasn't disclosed.

Judge Frank Caprio pictured in 2018. (Slaven Vlasic/Getty Images)
Judge Frank Caprio pictured in 2018. (Slaven Vlasic/Getty Images)

The mother was facing a $85 fine, when Judge Caprio brought up her young daughter Sofia to help him decide her punishment.

"Your mother has a ticket that's $85," he explained to the youngster in an exchange that was filmed for reality TV show, Caught in Providence, in 2019.

"Now, you're going to be honest, okay? I can charge her $85, or I can charge her something less. So, should I give her a break and not charge her $85?"

While Sofia agrees that her mom deserves a break, she then suggests that she's fined $100 instead.

Trying to talk her out of such a high figure, the judge suggested that he charge the mom $50 or nothing.

But the six-year-old felt $50 was the appropriate amount, to which her mom laughs and face palmed.

"Would it be okay with you if I charge her nothing?" Judge Caprio goes on to ask Sofia, but she still says 'no'.

Eventually her mom is able to plead her case to the youngster and promises her a new toy of some sort in favor of her not voting to have her charged.

Sofia still wasn't buying it, however.

Sofia was digging her mom into a deep hole. (Caught In Providence/YouTube)
Sofia was digging her mom into a deep hole. (Caught In Providence/YouTube)

Eventually Judge Caprio thanks her for her help and sends her back to her mom.

After all the back-and-forth with Sofia, he decided to dismiss the case.

People have since applauded the six-year-old for standing her ground.

"She don’t accept bribe and she knows she’s doing the right thing," one person praised on social media.

"I already have a big respect for that kid. Integrity," added a second.

While someone else quipped: "She an incorruptible judge."

"This kid has a future in the justice system," another person penned.

Elsewhere, Judge Caprio was also hailed for his kindness.

The internet has fallen in love with Judge Caprio. (Jessica Rinaldi/The Boston Globe via Getty Images)
The internet has fallen in love with Judge Caprio. (Jessica Rinaldi/The Boston Globe via Getty Images)

"I haven’t seen any other judges with this kind of compassion," said one X user.

"I have never met a judge as good as him, he is amazing," echoed another.

A third person went on: "We need more judges like him."

Caught in Providence was first aired in 2000 by ABC station WLNE-TV.

After a hiatus, the show returned in 2015 before going into national syndication.

Following it's ongoing popularity, Judge Caprio has gone to be become a well-loved TV favorite.

The newest season of the programme aired in 2019.

Featured Image Credit: Caught In Providence

Topics: Parenting, Court, Viral, Film and TV