• News
  • Film and TV
  • Music
  • Tech
  • Features
  • Celebrity
  • Politics
  • Weird
  • Community
  • Advertise
  • Terms
  • Privacy & Cookies
  • LADbible Group
  • LADbible
  • SPORTbible
  • GAMINGbible
  • Tyla
  • UNILAD Tech
  • FOODbible
  • License Our Content
  • About Us & Contact
  • Jobs
  • Latest
  • Topics A-Z
  • Authors
Facebook
Instagram
X
Threads
TikTok
YouTube
Submit Your Content
Tech Expert Reveals Why Elon Musk’s Promise Of Free Speech Will Fail

Home> News

Published 01:46 26 Apr 2022 GMT+1

Tech Expert Reveals Why Elon Musk’s Promise Of Free Speech Will Fail

Mike Masnick said the Tesla CEO doesn't understand the nuances that are involved in free speech and moderation on a site like Twitter.

Stewart Perrie

Stewart Perrie

Elon Musk has had his mammoth AU$61 million (US$44 million) bid for social media juggernaut Twitter accepted and he promises it will be a beacon for free speech. 

However, one tech expert has claimed the Tesla CEO actually understands very little about what free speech and content moderation in relation to operating one of the largest social media companies in the world.

Mike Masnick, the founder of Techdirt, analysed a TED interview Elon Musk had with Chris Anderson, soon after his Twitter bid was made public.

Advert

Masnick claims that Musk’s simplistic view on how free speech and social media should work is similar to that of tech experts in the early days of social media - learning that their beliefs aren’t actually reflected in reality. 

Masnick argues that Twitter has spent 15 years ‘experimenting and iterating its policies’ to deal with a variety of challenges, which Musk is ignoring. 

In the TED interview, Musk explained how he sees Twitter’s moderation coming down to what is allowed within the laws of a country.

Advert

He said: “In my view, Twitter should match the laws of the country. And, really, there’s an obligation to do that.”

Masnick claims this sentiment proves how little Musk actually knows about content moderation, citing that ‘free speech’ social network Parler fell into a similar problem.

Parler claimed they would only moderate speech if it violated the law, however, went against that claim when people took to the platform to mock Parler itself and post porn, both of which are protected by the United States’ first amendment. 

Masnick would also call Musk’s definition of free speech ‘utter nonsense’. 

Advert

Musk said: “A good sign as to whether there is free speech, is ‘is someone you don’t like allowed to say something you don’t like?’ And if that is the case, then you have free speech.”

He continued: “That is a sign of a healthy, functioning free speech situation.”

Masnick would argue the problem isn’t about someone saying something you dislike, but more about issues such as spam, abuse, threats of violence, and dangerously misleading information. 

Advert

Masnick said: “Musk not understanding any of that is just a representation of how little he understands this topic.”

Musk also outlined what Twitter’s main priority should be, however, Masnick claims it contradicts what Musk’s Twitter content moderation would be.

Musk said: “Frankly, the top priority I would have is eliminating the spam and scam bots and the bot armies that are on Twitter. You know, I think, these influence… they make the product much worse.”

Masnick believes this policy would require moderation and rules that would need to be enforced on the platform because spam is actually legal. 

Advert

Masnick believes Musk leaving the content moderation policy up to anything that is ‘legal’ is shortsighted. 

He claims that all early social media start-ups ‘started with a fundamental default towards allowing more speech and moderating less’.

But he added: “And they all realised over time that it’s a lot more nuanced than that.”

Featured Image Credit: Britta Pedersen/dpa-Zentralbild/dpa-pool/dpa/Alamy Live News. Alamy

Topics: Elon Musk, Twitter

Stewart Perrie
Stewart Perrie

Stewart Perrie is a Senior Journalist at LADbible. Stewart has covered the conflict in Syria for LADbible, interviewing a doctor on the front line, and has contributed to the hugely successful UOKM8 campaign. He is in charge of the LADbible Australia editorial content and social presence.

X

@stewartperrie

Advert

Advert

Advert

Choose your content:

an hour ago
2 hours ago
  • an hour ago

    Scientists explain why 'mankeeping' is the reason women are 'quiet-quitting' relationships

    It's all to do with a 'male friendship recession' where women are apparently picking up the slack...

    News
  • an hour ago

    Where to watch 28 Days Later and 28 Weeks Later as 28 Years Later is released

    The third instalment of the franchise hits theatres in America on June 20

    Film & TV
  • an hour ago

    Scientists issue disturbing warning with exactly how much time we have left to limit climate change

    Scientists have described it as 'crunch time' to reach a previously set target

    News
  • 2 hours ago

    Influencer found dead before husband took his own life allegedly shared disturbing Facebook post hours earlier

    Zaria Khadejah Carr allegedly made a plea before her death hours later in Georgia

    News
  • Expert responds to Elon Musk’s calls for Donald Trump to be impeached and shares legal break down
  • Elon Musk reveals results of drug test after claims he was taking ketamine while in the White House
  • Everyone's saying the same thing after Elon Musk explains why he U-turned on Trump Epstein claims
  • Tech expert with support from Elon Musk claims ‘over $100 billion’ in US taxpayer money is being wasted or stolen