Advert

Depp Heard Trial Resumes: All The Possible Outcomes

Published 
| Last updated 

Depp Heard Trial Resumes: All The Possible Outcomes

Johnny Depp and Amber Heard's libel trial has resumed today, however there are only two weeks left before the jurors must decide.

The pair have been embroiled in an intense four weeks of testimony amid a $50 million lawsuit Johnny Depp filed against his ex-wife over an op-ed piece she wrote for The Washington Post in 2018 in which she claimed to be 'a public figure representing domestic abuse'.

While Amber Heard didn't mention Depp by name, the Pirates of the Caribbean actor has argued the insinuation has not only ruined his career but his reputation too.

Advert

As the trial resumes at Fairfax County District Courthouse, Heard is set to be questioned by Depp's legal team.

However, experts have weighed in on just what could happen in two weeks time when the trial ends and what could be the most important factors to be weighed up in the jurors' final resolution.

Experts have weighed in on the possible outcomes of the Johnny Depp Amber Heard libel trial. Credit: Alamy
Experts have weighed in on the possible outcomes of the Johnny Depp Amber Heard libel trial. Credit: Alamy

The jury has so far heard four weeks of testimony, with the likes of doctors, forensic psychologists and members of Depp's security team having taken to the stand.

Advert

Insights have been given into the couple's honeymoon, Heard's mental state and violent texts sent by Depp about his former wife.

However, both actors' profession and skill for performing has been noted by experts as being the real focus and problem for the jury in their deliberations.

Amber Heard and Johnny Depp's skill for performing and profession has been noted by one expert as being one of the biggest factors in the jury's deliberations. Credit: Alamy
Amber Heard and Johnny Depp's skill for performing and profession has been noted by one expert as being one of the biggest factors in the jury's deliberations. Credit: Alamy

Both Heard and Depp have taken to the stand, with Heard detailing incidents of alleged abuse, such as the first time Depp 'hit' her.

Advert

Depp has denied hitting his ex-wife, or 'any woman' for that matter and claimed he instead is a 'victim of domestic violence'.

However, both have been accused of performing, with American radio and TV personality Howard Stern accusing Depp of 'overacting' and Heard outed for reportedly stealing lines from The Talented Mr Ripley.

Johnny Depp was accused of 'overacting' in the trial by Howard Stern. Credit: Alamy
Johnny Depp was accused of 'overacting' in the trial by Howard Stern. Credit: Alamy

Kimberly Lau, a partner at New York legal firm Warshaw Burstein, explained how difficult the jury will find it to be able to tell truth from lie given Depp and Heard are both distinguished actors.

Advert

She told Sky News: "Both sides have done a fair job at exposing the other's less-than-finer moments. What will make this trial particularly challenging for a jury is the fact that both parties are trained actors whose job is to make the audience believe they are, in fact, the role they play.

"The testimony of the witnesses and documentary evidence will be even more essential for the jury to determine who is really telling the truth and who may be merely acting out a role."

Legal partner Kimberly Lau noted how the 'the testimony of the witnesses and documentary evidence will be even more essential' because of Depp and Heard's status as actors. Credit: Alamy
Legal partner Kimberly Lau noted how the 'the testimony of the witnesses and documentary evidence will be even more essential' because of Depp and Heard's status as actors. Credit: Alamy

Matthew Dando, partner and media law expert at London firm Wiggin, reflected how Heard and Depp's appearances in court may also be being amped up even more due to the widespread media coverage surrounding the trial.

Advert

He told PA: "It will inevitably mean that the advocates are not just playing to the people in the courtroom, but directly through television... they're playing directly to the public."

While a legal expert has clarified the social media response to the trial will have no impact on the case, Dando noted it will 'definitely affect [...] the dynamic of the trial'.

Matthew Dando explained the media coverage will 'affect the dynamic of the trial'. Credit: Alamy
Matthew Dando explained the media coverage will 'affect the dynamic of the trial'. Credit: Alamy

Lau also noted how juries come with 'an inherent unpredictability' opposed to the case having been brought before a judge.

"Having a jury of several individuals – in this case, seven – makes a big difference in the deliberation process.

"The opinion of one is not enough; all seven must agree. And while judges, unlike juries, already have an understanding of the law, the jury is comprised of several individuals whose life experiences can have an impact on how they view and weigh the evidence at trial," the legal partner noted.

Lau noted the potential impact of jurors' own 'life experiences' on the result of the trial. Credit: Alamy
Lau noted the potential impact of jurors' own 'life experiences' on the result of the trial. Credit: Alamy

If Depp wins the case, the jury will have to decide how much of the $50 million he is awarded in damages, or whether the actor should receive less or more.

Even if Depp loses the case, the trial is a civil one opposed to criminal, which means the actor wouldn't be found guilty of a crime.

Lau noted how a loss could be potentially be more damaging for Heard due to her being younger than Depp and subsequently having more of her career left to be impacted.

Whether Depp or Heard win, Lau warned: "It will be tough for Depp to completely salvage his career even if he prevails at trial. The accusations may be enough to make some question the truth no matter what the outcome at trial.

"It's hard to unring a bell."

If you have a story you want to tell, send it to UNILAD via [email protected]  

Featured Image Credit: Alamy

Topics: News, Johnny Depp, Amber Heard, US News, Celebrity, Film and TV

Poppy Bilderbeck
More like this
Advert
Advert
Advert

Chosen for YouChosen for You

Film & TV

The Simpsons will finally reveal how they predict the future

5 hours ago

Most Read StoriesMost Read

Olivia Newton-John has died aged 73

2 days ago