• News
  • Film and TV
  • Music
  • Tech
  • Features
  • Celebrity
  • Politics
  • Weird
  • Community
  • Advertise
  • Terms
  • Privacy & Cookies
  • LADbible Group
  • LADbible
  • SPORTbible
  • GAMINGbible
  • Tyla
  • UNILAD Tech
  • FOODbible
  • License Our Content
  • About Us & Contact
  • Jobs
  • Latest
  • Topics A-Z
  • Authors
Facebook
Instagram
X
Threads
TikTok
YouTube
Submit Your Content
Prosecutors left with one question after woman accused of killing relatives with poisonous lunch found guilty

Home> News> World News

Published 10:15 7 Jul 2025 GMT+1

Prosecutors left with one question after woman accused of killing relatives with poisonous lunch found guilty

Erin Patterson previously pleaded not guilty to killing her in-laws with a poisonous lunch served in 2023

Emily Brown

Emily Brown

Prosecutors have acknowledged there's one question left in the case of Erin Patterson, the Australian woman found guilty of killing her in-laws by serving them poisonous mushrooms cooked into beef Wellington pastries.

Patterson, 50, has been convicted of three counts of murder and one of attempted murder following the deaths of her in-laws Gail and Don Patterson, as well as Gail's sister, Heather Wilkinson, in July 2023.

The deaths came after the family members went to Patterson's house in Leongatha for lunch, where she served them individual beef Wellington pastries which were later found to have contained poisonous death cap mushrooms.

Heather's husband, Ian Wilkinson, also ate the meal and became gravely ill, but ultimately survived.

Advert

Over the course of a nine-week trial, the jury heard details about Patterson's relationship with her estranged husband, Simon Patterson, who had been invited to the meal but decided not to attend.

Erin Patterson said she was devastated over the deaths of her in-laws (Nine News)
Erin Patterson said she was devastated over the deaths of her in-laws (Nine News)

Patterson had cooked one extra beef Wellington for the meal, but she denied that it was intended specifically for Simon.

She told the court: "I didn’t make that sixth one for Simon. It’s just an extra one. Simon wasn’t coming."

Advert

With the verdict now decided, there is one question that prosecutors working the case have acknowledged - what was Patterson's motive?

Addressing the court back in April, prosecutor Nanette Rogers SC warned the question may remain as she said: "You might be wondering, 'What is the motive?' You might still be wondering this at the end of this trial."

The prosecution did not suggest a specific motive while presenting its case, but Rogers explained: "You do not have to be satisfied what the motive was, or even that there was one".

Instead, Rogers explained that the jury simply would have to reject the defense's argument that the deaths were the result of a 'horrible foraging accident'.

Advert

Patterson's defense insisted that Patterson did not know the mushrooms she used in the meal were death caps, and that the entire incident was a tragic mix-up between store-bought mushrooms and wild mushrooms.

Speaking in her own defense, Patterson told the court she had researched ideas to find 'something special' to include in the meal, as she wanted to get away from the 'bland' flavor.

She claimed she believed she was adding dried fungi bought from an Asian supermarket into the meal, but added: "Now I think that there was a possibility that there were foraged ones in there as well."

Erin Patterson pleaded not guilty to killing her in-laws (10 News First)
Erin Patterson pleaded not guilty to killing her in-laws (10 News First)

Advert

In contrast, prosecutors alleged that Patterson had specifically researched and foraged the death cap mushrooms, pointing to evidence that a food dehydrator had been disposed of after she served her meal.

They also claimed that Patterson had chosen to cook individual pastries to avoid poisoning herself, serving herself on a different colored plate.

The jury departed the courtroom to begin their deliberations on June 30, and remained sequestered, meaning they stayed together in court-appointed accommodation, until they reached their decision. The jury then reached its verdict on July 7.

The jury was not tasked with deciding whether Patterson served her guests poisonous mushrooms, but whether she intended to kill them by doing so.

Featured Image Credit: 7NEWS Australia

Topics: Erin Patterson, Australia, Crime

Emily Brown
Emily Brown

Emily Brown is UNILAD Editorial Lead at LADbible Group. She first began delivering news when she was just 11 years old - with a paper route - before graduating with a BA Hons in English Language in the Media from Lancaster University. Emily joined UNILAD in 2018 to cover breaking news, trending stories and longer form features. She went on to become Community Desk Lead, commissioning and writing human interest stories from across the globe, before moving to the role of Editorial Lead. Emily now works alongside the UNILAD Editor to ensure the page delivers accurate, interesting and high quality content.

Advert

Advert

Advert

  • Woman accused of killing relatives with poisonous lunch claims she was trying to fix a 'bland' lunch
  • Woman accused of killing relatives with poisonous lunch 'lured them to her home to share fake cancer diagnosis'
  • Doctor reveals strange decision made by woman accused of killing relatives with poisonous lunch as messages shared in court
  • Mushroom cook accused of poisoning relatives reveals why she made an extra meal as she denies wanting to kill husband

Choose your content:

2 hours ago
3 hours ago
4 hours ago
  • 2 hours ago

    Lil Nas X arrested after police respond to reports of 'naked man' roaming the streets

    Lil Nas X has been detained, the LAPD have confirmed

    Celebrity
  • 3 hours ago

    World's most secretive plane seen flying over Area 51 'confirming' longstanding rumor

    I'm not saying its aliens... but it's gotta be aliens

    News
  • 4 hours ago

    Truth behind controversial new weight loss jab 'Reta' that's said to be 3 times stronger than Ozempic

    The new weight loss drug is yet to be approved for use

    News
  • 4 hours ago

    Millie Bobby Brown revealed what she thinks of adoption as she welcomes first child with Jake Bongiovi

    Millie Bobby Brown stunned many when she announced she had welcomed her first kid

    Celebrity