• News
  • Film and TV
  • Music
  • Tech
  • Features
  • Celebrity
  • Politics
  • Weird
  • Community
  • Advertise
  • Terms
  • Privacy & Cookies
  • LADbible Group
  • LADbible
  • SPORTbible
  • GAMINGbible
  • Tyla
  • UNILAD Tech
  • FOODbible
  • License Our Content
  • About Us & Contact
  • Jobs
  • Latest
  • Topics A-Z
  • Authors
Facebook
Instagram
X
Threads
TikTok
YouTube
Submit Your Content
Scientist claims humans have no free will and gives scientific reasoning behind it

Home> News> Health

Published 20:54 30 Oct 2023 GMT

Scientist claims humans have no free will and gives scientific reasoning behind it

Scientist Robert Sapolsky has conducted 'decades' of research delving into whether or not humans have free will

Poppy Bilderbeck

Poppy Bilderbeck

A scientist has concluded after 'decades' of research he doesn't believe humans have free will.

If you're desperate for more Black Mirror after already binge-watching the latest season straight after its release, then how about feeling like you've been physically dropped into an episode yourself instead?

Prepare yourself as we delve into the big old philosophical questions you normally save for 3.00am at the after party.

Whether or not humans have free will is a contentious topic of discussion.

Many scientists, philosophers and the rest of the population argue humans definitely have free will, take Bernardo Kastrup - who has a PhD in philosophy and works in some of the world's 'foremost research laboratories' - for instance.

Advert

In an article for the Scientific Journal in 2020, Kastrup defines free will as being 'if our choices are determined by that which we experientially identify with'.

He explained that his own 'tastes and preferences' are 'consciously felt by' him and his choices are then 'determined by these felt tastes and preferences'.

The scientist draws on 19th century philosopher Arthur Schopenhauer's argument that even if our sensory organs didn't sense something and prompt how we perceive it and then react to it, we'd still feel our own internal sense to choose what action to perform.

Kastrup resolves: "Therefore, prior to being represented we are essentially will. Our physical body is merely how our will presents itself to an external vantage point."

Advert

Ultimately, most scientists agree humans have some level of free will, but one particular scientist doesn't agree at all.

Do you believe humans have free will?
Pexels/ Sebastian Voortman

After looking into the subject of free will for 'decades,' Stanford University neurobiologist Robert Sapolsky says humans don't have any.

Sapolsky delves into the debate in his new book Determined: A Science of Life Without Free Will - published on 17 October - arguing most of all human behaviour is out of our conscious control.

Advert

The scientist resolves: "The world is really screwed up and made much, much more unfair by the fact that we reward people and punish people for things they have no control over.

"We’ve got no free will. Stop attributing stuff to us that isn’t there."

Robert Sapolsky doesn't believe humans have free will.
Stanford University

According to Sapolsky, humans are 'nothing more or less than the sum of that which we could not control - our biology, our environments, their interactions'.

Advert

In an interview with CultureLab, he adds: "In terms of my orientation, my basic approach is you look at a behaviour and someone has just done something that’s wonderful or awful or ambiguously in-between or in the eyes of the beholder, but some behaviour has happened, and you ask, 'Why did that occur?' and you’re asking a whole hierarchy of questions."

For Sapolsky these questions begin with 'which neurons did what, ten milliseconds before,' and go all the way back to taking into account 'this morning's hormone levels' and their impact on your brain's sensitivity to the stimuli; before going even further back to previous months of potential trauma all the way to 'childhood and foetal environment' and genes.

The scientist even goes as far to argue you should then ask questions looking as far back as the culture of people's ancestors and evolution as a whole.

Sapolsky delves into the argument in his book 'Determined: Life Without Free Will'.
Amazon

Advert

Sapolsky resolves: "What you see at that point is, not just saying, 'Wow, when you look at all these different disciplines, collectively, they’re showing we’re just biological machines,' but they’re not all these different disciplines. They’re all one continuous one.

"If you’re talking about genes, by definition, genes and behaviour, by definition, you’re talking about evolution and you’re talking about neurobiology and genetic variance and neuronal function. If you’re talking about, you know, early trauma in life, you’re talking about epigenetics and you’re talking about adult propensity.

"So, they’re all one continuous seam of influences, and when you look at it that way, there’s not a damn crack anywhere in there to shoehorn in a notion of free will."

Featured Image Credit: Wikimedia Commons/Cmichel67/Pexels

Topics: US News, Science, World News, Mental Health, Health

Poppy Bilderbeck
Poppy Bilderbeck

Poppy Bilderbeck is a Senior Journalist at LADbible Group. She graduated from The University of Manchester in 2021 with a First in English Literature and Drama, where alongside her studies she was Editor-in-Chief of The Tab Manchester. Poppy is most comfortable when chatting about all things mental health, is proving a drama degree is far from useless by watching and reviewing as many TV shows and films as possible and is such a crisp fanatic the office has been forced to release them in batches.

Advert

Advert

Advert

Choose your content:

11 hours ago
13 hours ago
  • 11 hours ago

    Passengers left screaming after hole cracks open on world’s biggest cruise ship's waterslide

    A man was reportedly left 'sliced open' after going down the slide

    News
  • 11 hours ago

    South Park sparks controversy showing Dora The Explorer being sex-trafficked to 'Mar-a-Lago island'

    South Park has made yet another swipe at the president

    Film & TV
  • 13 hours ago

    James Van Der Beek reveals subtle early cancer symptom he dismissed before shock diagnosis

    The Dawson's Creek alumni announced his cancer diagnosis last year

    Celebrity
  • 13 hours ago

    Former Superman actor announces he's joining ICE in a bid to 'save America'

    Dean Cain is urging others to follow in his footsteps

    News
  • Scientists discover humans have 'hope molecules' and reveal how the body can 'produce antidepressants'
  • What happens if you eat uranium after nuclear chemist 'ate' it to prove it was harmless
  • Scientist claims to have evidence 'our entire universe is trapped inside a black hole'
  • Boss allows employees to have 'masturbation breaks' as she explains bizarre reason behind it